What do the respected Muftis say regarding the following matter?
There are six brothers and three sisters in a family. Of the six brothers, three have impaired mental faculties, and one of the sisters is also ill. The annual cost of her medication is 40,000 rupees.
One of the brothers bears the cost of his sister’s medication, even though he himself lives in a rented house. The other brothers do not contribute towards purchasing her medication.
However, the brothers and sisters jointly own a piece of land in their village, which has been rented out. The annual rental income from this land is 30,000 rupees, and the land and its rental income are jointly owned by all the heirs.
Is it permissible under Islamic law for the brother who pays for his sister’s medication to use the annual rental income from this jointly owned land to purchase her medication? Or would doing so be impermissible?
Note: Both parents have passed away, and the only heirs are the six brothers and three sisters mentioned above. The land is jointly owned by all of them.
If the land mentioned in the question was inherited from the deceased parents, then all the heirs mentioned in the question are entitled to the land and the income generated from it according to their respective shares prescribed by Islamic law.
It is not permissible under Shariah for any one heir to use the jointly owned property or its income according to their own wishes while depriving the other heirs of their rightful shares.
Therefore, in the situation described, the brother who bears the cost of his sick sister’s medication is not permitted to spend the entire rental income from the jointly owned land on his sister’s medication without the consent of the other heirs.
Rather, after receiving the rental income, he must distribute it among all the heirs according to their respective shares.
Once each heir has received their rightful share, if any heir voluntarily gives their share towards the sister’s medical treatment, medication, or other related expenses, this is permissible.
The healthy brothers should likewise contribute towards their sister’s treatment in this manner.
کما فی دررالحکام: تقسم حاصلات الأموال المشتركة في شركة الملك بين أصحابها بنسبة حصصهم، يعني إذا كانت حصص الشريكين متساوية أي مشتركة مناصفة فتقسم بالتساوي وإذا لم تكن متساوية بأن يكون لأحدهما الثلث وللآخر الثلثان فتقسم الحاصلات على هذه النسبة؛ لأن نفقات هذه الأموال هي بنسبة حصصهما،اھ(تقسيم حاصلات الأموال المشتركة،ج: 3،ص: 26،مط: دارالجیل)
و فی الدرالمختار: لا يجوز التصرف في مال غيره بلا إذنه ولا ولايته،اھ(كتاب الغصب،ج: 6،ص: 617،مط: دارالفکر)
و فی العنایة: (والنفقة لكل ذي رحم محرم إذا كان صغيرا فقيرا أو كانت امرأة بالغة فقيرة أو كان ذكرا بالغا فقيرا زمنا أو أعمى) لأن الصلة في القرابة القريبة واجبة دون البعيدة، والفاصل أن يكون ذا رحم محرم، وقد قال الله تعالى {وعلى الوارث مثل ذلك} وفي قراءة عبد الله بن مسعود " وعلى الوارث ذي الرحم المحرم مثل ذلك ثم لا بد من الحاجة والصغر والأنوثة والزمانة والعمى أمارة الحاجة لتحقق العجز، اھ(باب النفقة،ج: 4،ص: 419،مط: دارالفکر)