What do the esteemed Muftis say regarding the following matter?
Our sister, Hasan Ara, passed away in 2019. At the time of her death, her heirs were her husband, Muhammad Arshad, and one daughter, Zahra Fatima.
At the time of Hasan Ara’s death, her father, Muhammad Moinuddin, was alive. He passed away in June 2022. Hasan Ara’s mother is, by the grace of Allah, still alive.
Since Hasan Ara passed away during the lifetime of both her parents, does Hasan Ara herself have any share in her parents’ property? Or, does her daughter, Zahra Fatima, have any share?
Kindly explain the Shar‘i ruling regarding this matter in detail.
Jazakumullahu Khairan
It should be clarified that if a son or daughter of the deceased dies during the lifetime of the deceased, then according to Sahri'a, the deceased child’s offspring do not become entitled to a share of the deceased’s estate, in the presence of his other close heirs such as the deceased’s sons or daughters.
Therefore, in the case in question, since the questioner’s sister, Hasan Ara, passed away during the lifetime of her father, the deceased Muhammad Moinuddin, her children do not have a legally prescribed share in the inheritance of their maternal grandfather or grandmother in the presence of the latter’s surviving sons and daughters.
Accordingly, it is not permissible for the questioner’s niece to demand a share in the inheritance of her maternal grandfather or grandmother as per Shari'a, and she should refrain from making such a claim.
However, if the adult heirs of the deceased, out of their own free will and as an act of maintaining family ties, wish to give something to their orphaned nephew or nieces, they are entitled to do so. Such an act would, indeed, be a source of reward and blessing for them. However, giving them anything in this manner is not obligatory upon the heirs under Islamic law.
کما فی رد المحتار : وشروطہ : ثلاثۃ : موت مورث حقيقة، أو حكما كمفقود، أو تقديرا كجنين فيه غرة ووجود وارثه عند موته حيا حقيقة أو تقديراالخ (کتاب الفرائض،ج:6،ص:758،ط: سعید)۔
و فی الہندیہ:وأما حجب الحرمان فنقول: ستة لا يحجبون أصلا، الأب والابن والزوج والأم والبنت والزوجة ومن عدا هؤلاء فالأقرب يحجب الأبعد كالابن يحجب أولاد الابن والأخ لأبوين يحجب الإخوة لأب ومن يدلي بشخص لا يرث معه إلا أولاد الأم.اھ(كتاب الفرائض ،الباب الرابع في الحجب ،ج :6،ص: 452،ط:ماجدیۃ)