(+92) 0317 1118263

Will a person who has come from Saudi Arabia to Pakistan fast for 31 days?

Fasting and Ramadan,Rules for Ramadan,Will a person who has come from Saudi Arabia to Pakistan fast for 31 days?

Fatwa No :
98511
| Date :
0000-00-00
عبادات / روزہ و رمضان / احکام رمضان

Will a person who has come from Saudi Arabia to Pakistan fast for 31 days?

What do the respected Muftis and Islamic scholars say in accordance with Islamic law, on the following matter:
A person travels to Saudi Arabia with the intention of performing Umrah, and his return journey takes place during the month of Ramadan. Since, generally, the crescent is sighted in Saudi Arabia one day earlier than in Pakistan, there may consequently be a one-day difference in the number of fasts observed.
Suppose, in the situation described, the crescent of Shawwal is sighted in Pakistan after completing thirty days of Ramadan. In such a case, the person who has already observed thirty-one fasts due to the difference in the dates of Ramadan in Saudi Arabia and Pakistan—should he observe the thirty-first fast?
Similarly, suppose a person travels to the Haramain (Makkah or Madinah) during Ramadan with the intention of performing Itikaf, and his flight from Saudi Arabia to Pakistan arrives on the day of Eid al-Fitr in Saudi Arabia, whereas that same day is the final day of fasting in Pakistan. In this situation, what is the ruling regarding the fast that he has missed? Will he be required to make it Qadha?
Jazakumullahu khairan

الجوابُ حامِدا ًو مُصلیِّا ً

With regard to observing or breaking the fast, the primary consideration is the person’s current location.
Therefore, if the person in question arrives in Pakistan and it is the 30th day of Ramadan there, then this fast will also be obligatory upon him.
However, in the second situation mentioned, if the person arrives in Pakistan after having broken his fast in Saudi Arabia, then making up (qada) that particular fast will not be obligatory upon him. Nevertheless, he must spend the remainder of that day refraining from eating and drinking, just like the other people who are fasting.

مأخَذُ الفَتوی

کما فی البحر الرائق شرح كنز الدقائق: (قوله من رأى هلال رمضان أو الفطر ورد قوله صام فإن أفطر قضى فقط) لقوله تعالى في هلال رمضان {فمن شهد منكم الشهر فليصمه} [البقرة: 185] ، وهذا قد شهده والحديث في هلال الفطر «صومكم يوم تصومون وفطركم يوم تفطرون» والناس لم يفطروا في هذا اليوم فوجب عليه موافقتهم اھ (2/ 286)
و في السراجية : اهل بلدة صاموا للروية بثلثين يوما واهل بلدة اخرى تسعة وعشرين الرؤية فعلى هولاء قضاء يوم الا اذا كان بين البلدتين بتائن بحيث تختلف المطالع اھ (ص: ۳۱)

And Allah knows best
عبد الرحمن عُفی عنه
دار الافتاء جامعه بنوریه عالمیه

Fatwa No 98511 Verify Now
0     199
Related Fatawa Related Fatawa
  • Breaking one's fast to give blood

    Unicode   Scanned   English   0 Rules for Ramadan
  • Sounding a siren to wake people up for Sehri

    Unicode   Scanned   English   1 Rules for Ramadan
  • What is the ruling for the one who witnesses the moon of Ramadan or Shawwal alone?

    Scanned   English   0 Rules for Ramadan
  • Specific scenario about fasting

    Unicode   English   4 Rules for Ramadan
  • please guide on the timing of iftar and saher during ramzan?

    English   0 Rules for Ramadan
  • to observe Fasting and Eid etc. in accordance to Saudi Arab?

    English   0 Rules for Ramadan
  • Sleeping with Wife while Fasting and Giving Zakat to Husband

    English   0 Rules for Ramadan
  • Breaking of Fast is connected with the Sun set.

    English   0 Rules for Ramadan
  • started Roza in Saudi Arabia. will come to Pakistan on 30 Ramadan

    English   1 Rules for Ramadan
  • can I skip fasting when I am away. And complete fastings when I am back?

    English   0 Rules for Ramadan
  • Making a bequest of a sick person to pay Fidya on his missed fasting

    Unicode   English   0 Rules for Ramadan
  • Will a person who has come from Saudi Arabia to Pakistan fast for 31 days?

    Unicode   English   0 Rules for Ramadan
  • When paying the compensation (Fidyah) for missed fasts, is it permissible to use that money to feed poor and needy people?

    Unicode   English   0 Rules for Ramadan
  • Ruling on Kaffara if a person engages in sexual intercourse during the month of Ramadan due to ignorance of the law

    Unicode   English   0 Rules for Ramadan
  • Does placing naswar (a smokeless tobacco product) in the mouth invalidate the fast?

    Unicode   English   0 Rules for Ramadan
  • “Does using medicinal drops in the eyes, nose, or ears break the fast?

    Unicode   English   0 Rules for Ramadan
  • The ruling on fasting and celebrating Eid in contradiction to the announcement of the Ru’yat e Hilal Committee.

    Unicode   English   0 Rules for Ramadan
  • Observing Fast before offering Qurbani

    Unicode   English   0 Rules for Ramadan
...
Related Topics Relative Topics