Respected Islamic Scholars,
Please provide guidance regarding the following matter:
Our parents are old and suffering from illness. Our father is over 95 years old, and our mother is approximately 85 years old. Our father has some money in a bank account in his name, and he also owns a personal house.
We are four siblings in total: two brothers and two sisters. Both brothers and our elder sister are married and live in their own homes. Our younger sister was married, but she was subsequently divorced for some reason. Since her divorce, she has been living with our parents for approximately twenty years.
Now our father says:
“I want to transfer the money in my bank account and my personal house to my younger daughter, Nishad Akhtar's name.”
Our elder sister also supports this decision and tells our father to transfer everything to the younger daughter.
We would therefore like to seek Islamic guidance on the following questions:
1. Is it permissible according to Shariah for a father to deprive any of his heirs of their rightful share of inheritance?
2. To what extent is our father's proposed action—transferring all his money and his personal house to his younger daughter—permissible according to Shariah?
3. What is the Islamic ruling regarding our elder sister's role in facilitating or encouraging our father to give all his property to the younger sister?
Please provide detailed guidance in this regard
It should be clarified that Islamic law commands and encourages parents to maintain justice and fairness among their children. The Prophet Muhammad (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) strongly disapproved of giving a gift to one child while depriving the other children.
Therefore, in the situation described, although the questioner’s father is of advanced age, if he is not suffering from a life-threatening illness, then, according to Shariah, he retains the right to dispose of his property as he wishes during his lifetime, including his house, money in the bank, and other possessions.
Accordingly, if the questioner’s father wishes, while he is in a state of health and soundness, to give his house or bank balance exclusively to his younger daughter, then the questioner or his other brother does not have the legal authority under Shariah to prevent or stop him from doing so
However, giving unequal gifts to children without a valid reason, or completely depriving some children of gifts, is not permissible according to Shariah. Therefore, the father giving all of his property exclusively to his younger daughter, and the elder daughter supporting and encouraging the father in this matter, is inappropriate. If this is being done without a legitimate reason, with the intention of depriving the sons of their rights, then it would be a religiously impermissible act (haram), and they would be sinful for doing so.
Therefore, if the father wishes to distribute his property among his children during his lifetime, he should, after retaining what he needs for his own requirements, divide the remaining property into four equal portions and distribute them equally among all his children
However, if the father wishes to give his daughter somewhat more because of her particular needs and to protect her from financial dependence on others in the future, there is no harm in doing so. Nevertheless, rather than completely depriving the sons, he should also give them something so that their feelings are considered and their hearts are kept content
کما فی مجمع الأنهر :(وهبة المقعد) وهو العاجز عن المشي لداء في رجليه (والمفلوج) الفلج داء يعرض في نصف البدن فيمنعه عن الحس والحركة الإرادية (والأشل) وهو الذي في يده ارتعاش وحركة (والمسلول) وهو الذي يكون به مرض السل وهو قرح في الرئة تعتبر وصيته (من كل ماله إن طال) مدة مرضه وقدروه بالسنة (ولم يخف موته منه) أي من المرض (وإلا) أي، وإن لم يطل مدة مرضه وخيف موته منه (فمن ثلثه) أي ثلث ماله يعني أن من كان مبتلى بواحد من هذه الأمراض وتصرف بشيء من التبرعات قبل تمام سنة مشتملة على الفصول الأربعة كان المرض مرض الموت فتعتبر تبرعاته من ثلث ماله، وإن مات بعد تمام السنة من حين تبرعه تبين أنه لم يكن مريضا مرض الموت؛ لأنه إذا سلم في فصول السنة الأربعة التي كل واحد منها مظنة الهلاك صار المرض بمنزلة طبع من طبائعه وخرج صاحبه من أحكام المرضى حتى لا يشتغل بالتداوي كما في الدرر.وفي البزازية والمريض الذي يكون تصرفه من الثلث بأن يكون ذا فراش بحيث لا يطيق القيام لحاجته وتجوز له الصلاة قاعدا ويخاف عليه الموت كالفالج أو صار خشنا أو يابس الشق لا يكون له حكم المريض إلا إذا تغير حاله عن ذلك ومات من ذلك التغير فما فعل في حال التغير فمن الثلث قال الفضلي مرض الموت أن لا يخرج إلى حوائج نفسه وعليه اعتمد في التجريد انتهى.اھ(باب ارکان الوصیۃ،ج:2،ص:696،ط:دار إحياء التراث العربي)
و فی الجامع لأحكام الوقف والهبات والوصايا :القول الأول: أن تبرع المريض مرض الموت لوارثه بشيء، أو بأزيد من الثلث لغير وارث وإن قل موقوف على إجازة بقية الورثة، فإن أجازوه نفذ، وعليه تعتبر تنفيذا لهبة مورثهم، وإن ردوه بطل.وهو قول الحنفية، وقول للمالكية ،وأحد قولي الشافعية وهو الأظهر ، وقول الحنابلة.( المسألة الثانية حكم هبته لوارث أو بأكثر من الثلث من حيث إجازة الوارث،ج:5،ص:271،ط: وزارة الأوقاف والشؤون الإسلامية ، قطر)
The ruling on a father transferring ownership of his house in documents only to one son
English 0 Gift