Assalamu Alaikum,
I would like to seek guidance regarding some property that is registered in the name of my late mother. The property was purchased by my late father, after their marriage, in my late mother’s name. The registration and original documents were also in my mother’s name and remain so to this day.
During my father’s lifetime, there was no dispute or disagreement between my parents regarding this property. My father had purchased the property specifically in my mother’s name, although he himself used to manage the rent and other matters relating to the property.
The approximate value of the property is around 9 million rupees (90 lakh). We now wish to distribute it according to Islamic law.
We are three sisters and have no brother. My maternal grandmother (my late mother’s mother) is still alive. My mother also has two brothers (maternal uncles) and three sisters (maternal aunts) who are alive. My maternal grandfather (my mother’s father) passed away during my mother’s lifetime.
In this situation, we would like to know, according to Shariah, whether this property will be distributed only among the three of us sisters, or whether my maternal grandmother, maternal uncles, maternal aunts, or any other relatives are also entitled to a share.
For additional context, at the time of my father’s death, his surviving heirs were his wife (our mother), three daughters, and two sisters.
Jazakum Allahu Khairan for your guidance.
It should be made clear that merely putting something or a property in someone’s name, or verbally giving it to someone, does not make that person its owner according to Shariah, unless they are given actual possession of the property along with complete authority to exercise ownership and dispose of it.
Therefore, in the situation described, if the father merely registered the aforementioned property in his wife’s name but did not give her actual ownership, possession, and authority to manage or dispose of the property as an owner, then the late wife did not become the owner of the property merely because her name appeared on the documents.
Rather, the property would continue to remain the ownership of the father. Consequently, after the father’s death, this property must also be included in the deceased father’s other estate and distributed among his heirs according to their respective shares prescribed by Shariah.
کما في التاترخانية: وأما شرائط صحتها فأنواع ،أما في الموهوب فهو أن يكون الموهوب مقبوضا حتى لا يثبت الملك للموهوب له قبل القبض و أن يكون الموهوب مقسوما اذا كان ما يحتمل القسمة وأن يكون الموهوب متميزا عن غير الموهوب و لا يكون متصلا ولا مشغولا بغير الموهوب (كتاب الهبة ، ج: ١٤، ص؛ ٤١٢،ناشر ؛ حقانية )
وفي الشامية: وقوله: بخلاف جعلته باسمك) قال في البحر: قيد بقوله: لك؛ لأنه لو قال: جعلته باسمك، لا يكون هبة؛ ولهذا قال في الخلاصة: لو غرس لابنه كرما إن قال: جعلته لابني، يكون هبة، وإن قال: باسم ابني، لا يكون هبة، ولو قال: أغرس باسم ابني، فالأمر متردد، وهو إلى الصحة أقرب اهـ. وفي المتن من الخانية بعد هذا قال: جعلته لابني فلان، يكون هبة؛ لأن الجعل عبارة عن التمليك، وإن قال: أغرس باسم ابني، لا يكون هبة،اه (كتاب الهبة، ج: ٥، ص: ٦٨٩، مط: سعيد)
The ruling on a father transferring ownership of his house in documents only to one son
English 0 Gift