My name is Shaista. I am unmarried. My father and brother have passed away, and I am 38 years old. I live with my mother.
My brother-in-law wishes to travel for Umrah and take my mother with him so that she can perform Umrah. My mother has asked me to accompany her, and I also intend to perform Umrah. Alhamdulillah, I am financially able to perform Umrah and can afford the journey.
However, my brother-in-law has refused, saying that he is a non-mahram to me and that I cannot perform Umrah by travelling with him.
In light of Islamic teachings, is there any permissible solution in this situation? Kindly guide me regarding the ruling and whether I may accompany my mother and brother-in-law for Umrah under these circumstances.
I would be grateful for guidance on the matter in accordance with Islamic law.
It should be understood that, according to Islamic law, it is not permissible for a woman to undertake a Shar‘i journey (a distance of 48 miles or more) without a mahram, nor is it permissible for her to travel with a non-mahram man, even if other women are accompanying her.
Therefore, in the situation described, since the petitioner’s brother-in-law is a non-mahram to her, his refusal to take her along for Umrah is correct according to Islamic law.
Accordingly, if the petitioner currently has no mahram available, she should postpone performing Umrah until a mahram becomes available. She must refrain from travelling with her non-mahram brother-in-law merely because of her desire to perform Umrah.
کما في الصحيح للامام مسلم رحمہ اللہ:عن أبي سعيد الخدري قال: قال رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم: « لا يحل لامرأة تؤمن بالله واليوم الآخر أن تسافر سفرا يكون ثلاثة أيام فصاعدا إلا ومعها أبوها، أو ابنها، أو زوجها، أو أخوها، أو ذو محرم منها ». (باب سفر المرأة مع محرم إلى حج وغيره، ج: 1، ص: 691، رقم الحدیث: 1340، مکتبۃالبشریٰ)
وفی الدر المختار: (و) مع (زوج أو محرم) ولو عبدا أو ذميا أو برضاع (الیٰ قولہ) لامرأة حرة ولو عجوزا في سفر ، الخ
وفی رد المحتار تحت قول الدر( ومع زوج أو محرم): هذا وقوله ومع عدم عدة عليها شرطان مختصان بالمرأة فلذا قال لامرأة وما قبلهما من الشروط مشترك والمحرم من لا يجوز له مناكحتها على التأبيد بقرابة أو رضاع أو صهرية كما في التحفة، الخ (كتاب الحج، ج: 2، ص: 464، مط: سعید کراچی)