(+92) 0317 1118263

Doing Raf-Al-Yadain (Raising the Hands) in Optional Prayers

Prayer,Rules of Namaz,Doing Raf-Al-Yadain (Raising the Hands) in Optional Prayers

Fatwa: 3135
Doing Raf-Al-Yadain (Raising the Hands) in Optional Prayers

الاستفتاء

A person who is connected to the Hanafi School of Thought at times perform Nafl Namaz with Raf'a Yadain (Raising hands) and Jalsa e Isthirahath (Sitting before standing for 2nd or 3rd Raka'at). Purpose is to practice according to those Ahadees also. His intention and the way of practicing is proper or should he stay within the limit of his Fiqhi School of Thought irrespective of Fardh or Nafl?

الجواب حامدا و مصلیا

In the name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful
According to the light of Shar'ee evidences, preference is given to not raising the hands during Salah other than for the Takbeer-e-Tahreema (the opening Takbeer).
The reason behind this is that in the outset, the messenger of Allahﷺ used to raise his hands throughout the Salah, however, when the order of observing tranquility in Salah descended, he also abandoned raising his hands throughout the Salah to the extent that during the last stages of his life, he performed Salah without raising his hands except for the Takbeer-e-Tahreema. There are also some instances where the prohibition of raising the hands has been narrated. Therefore, it is not correct for an adherent of Hanafi school of thought to do Raf-al-Yadain in spite of having strong evidence of it being omitted, irrespective of whether it is done in Fard or Nafl Salah. Hence, it is necessary to refrain from this practice, and act upon the light of Ahadith in according to the Hanafi school of thought. Some reference from Ahadith are provided hereunder.
Narration of Hadhrat Jabir bin Samurah Radhiyallahu Anhu in Muslim, Vol 1, p 181.
Narration of Hadhrat Bara’a bin Aazib Radhiyallahu Anhu in Abu Da’ood, Vol 1, p 109.
Narration of Hadhrat Alqama Radhiyallahu Anhu in Thirmizi, Vol 1, p 35.
Allah knows best.

Allah Knows Better
Darulifta Jamia Binoria Aalamia
Fatwa No 3135 Verification
Categories
Related Fatawa
Performing missed Farz Salat the Niyyat of the first missed Salat or last3583 684 Prayer (Salat) in t-shirts or half arm shirts.3604 565 Doing Raf-Al-Yadain (Raising the Hands) in Optional Prayers3135 623 someone leaves off the four Rakats Sunnat of Zuhr Salah 39481 567 Performing Namaz while Restraining the Need to Relieve Oneself3636 666 Is it allowed to combine Zuhr and Asr why one is traveling35577 1379 Is it permissible to perform Salat-e-Tasbeeh?2602 804 Can one perform Salah while wearing this T-shirt28836 1132 There are heaters placed in front of the masjid is copying the Jews38873 530 the spread of Covid is possible if the worshipers stand together40619 610 Till what time, the days Asar Namaz could be performed?6378 583 To pray Zuhr and Asr prayers together36419 744 The law for Namaz of one who is excused 40611 685 To what extent should the hands be raised during Takbeer-e-Tahreema?40387 622 Leaving off the Maghrib Salah like this to perform it afterwards is not proper29924 593 the way of performing Witr Namaz according to all four Imams.6123 728 Tablighi lecture is being delivered someone is performing Nalf26932 539 Fajar prayer is going on, should one perform the Sunnat Salah35673 501 Running while going for Salah, inside or outside of the Masjid37310 568 Salah performed in a room where there are handicrafts of horses and angels25868 579 Here in Ireland I can find two or three different timings of Salat6323 469 walking in front of a person who is performing Namaz6391 529 Is it prohibited to crackle fingers while in Namaz?5405 464 whose Asar Namaz is due, gets the congregational Namaz of Maghrib,6104 479 Qadha Namaz - قضاء نماز - of an old aged lady?6440 466